May 1 has come and gone. Deposits are in. The Class of 2026 has scattered itself across the country, and for the first time we can look at this admissions cycle as a closed system instead of a forecast.
This is not a "where they got in" post. The students who said yes to Vanderbilt on May 1st are not why we're writing. The students who are about to sit down in June and start their applications — those are the readers I have in mind. The cycle that just ended is a teacher, and it taught five things worth carrying forward.
If you read our piece on the Demographic Paradox in December, this is its sequel. The "enrollment cliff" is real and the "application inflation" is real, and this year they kept colliding in stranger and stranger ways.
Pattern 1: ED Kept Eating the Cycle — and ED II Is No Longer a Backup
The headline numbers from Early Decision rounds this fall were not subtle. Selective schools again filled 50–60% of their incoming class through binding early rounds. Penn, Duke, Brown, Cornell, Dartmouth, Northwestern — at all of them, the regular round was effectively a coin flip with the coin weighted against the applicant.
What changed this year is what happened in January. ED II at Vanderbilt, Emory, NYU, Tufts, WashU, and Bowdoin stopped feeling like a "backup binding round" and started functioning as a deliberate second move. Families who used ED II well treated it as their second-favorite school, not as a fallback. The students who applied ED II in January without a plan — the ones who scrambled because their ED I came back as a deny or defer — were noticeably behind.
💡 What this means for the rising senior reading this in May: By early November, you should have an ED school and an ED II school decided. Not one with the other as a "maybe." Both. This is the planning conversation to have during the June visit window, not in October.
If you want the mechanics of how ED, ED II, and EA stack against each other for Texas families, our Early Decision vs. Early Action 2025 guide walks through the math.
Pattern 2: Test-Required Came Back Faster Than Families Expected
For three years, "test-optional" was the default assumption. This year that assumption collapsed.
Dartmouth, Yale, Brown, Harvard, Caltech, MIT, Stanford, Georgetown, and UT Austin all required scores for the Class of 2026 cycle or announced reinstatement. At the schools that stayed test-optional, the median submitted score climbed again — meaning "optional" became, in practice, "optional for the bottom half of your class."
Families who held out hope that their student could skip testing entirely found themselves at a disadvantage by the time fall applications came around. The digital SAT format is now mature, the ACT has its own enhanced format, and the question is no longer whether to test but when to start.
✨ What this means for the rising junior: Test planning needs to start now — not in junior spring. The students who walked into senior year with a finished, satisfactory score on the books were the ones who could spend their fall on essays instead of test prep.
We wrote about how Google's Gemini SAT tool can compress prep time. That advice is more relevant now than when we wrote it.
Pattern 3: The Headline Admit Rate Stopped Meaning What Families Thought It Meant
The most painful surprises this cycle came from families who built lists using a school's overall admit rate without checking the admit rate for the specific major.
Computer Science, business, and nursing at flagship publics ran 2–4× harder than the school's headline number. UT Austin's overall admit rate looks one way; CS at UT looks completely different. McCombs direct-admit business, UNC Kenan-Flagler, Michigan Ross, Wharton, Cornell Dyson — these were standalone-difficult admissions, not subsets of the parent school.
The same was true on the engineering side. Purdue Engineering, Georgia Tech, Texas A&M Engineering — separately competitive from the rest of the university and often more selective than the institution's reputation suggested.
💡 What this means for the rising senior: "What's your admit rate?" is the wrong question. *"What's the admit rate for my major, direct admit, this year?"* is the right one. A school can be a "match" for an English major and a "reach" for the same student applying to CS. Build the list around that distinction, not around the front-page number.
Pattern 4: The AI-Essay Flattening Was Real, and Authenticity Got Rewarded
This was the first cycle where admissions officers spoke openly — in podcasts, on conference panels, in off-the-record dinners — about reading essays and feeling the cadence of generative AI in the slush pile.
The result was not what the AI-doom crowd predicted. Readers did not stop being able to tell. They got better at telling. And the essays that stood out were specific, weird, and locally anchored. A real story about a specific moment in a specific Frisco classroom beat a polished "leadership journey" essay nearly every time.
This is the application-cycle proof of the thesis in AI and the Age of Information Abundance. When everyone has access to the same polishing tool, the premium on the un-polishable parts of your story goes up, not down.
✨ What this means for the rising senior: The essay you draft in June should sound like you, in your voice, about a moment your friends would recognize as yours. If a stranger could have written it, rewrite it. The Class of 2026 students who got into reach schools did not write the most beautiful essays — they wrote the most identifiable ones.
Pattern 5: The Texas Publics Got Harder for Texas Kids, and OOS Flagships Got Harder for Everyone
For Collin County families specifically, the most consequential pattern of the year happened close to home.
UT Austin's auto-admit threshold tightened again. The CAP program (Coordinated Admission) reshuffled its flow. A&M's competitiveness climbed across the board — engineering and Mays Business especially. SMU and TCU continued their multi-year climb in selectivity and yield, no longer behaving like the "Texas privates" they were ten years ago.
Out of state, the flagships that Frisco families have historically considered as matches — UNC, UVA, Michigan, UCLA, Berkeley — ran single-digit OOS admit rates again. Indiana, Wisconsin, and Ohio State stayed accessible but climbed.
💡 What this means for Collin County families: The list has to be honest at every tier.
- 🎯 Likely / safety tier: UT Dallas, Texas Tech, UT Arlington, UNT, University of Houston — with honors college admission as a positioning move
- ⚖️ Match tier: Texas A&M (likely a match, not a safety, depending on major), Baylor, TCU
- 🎯 Match tier, out of state: Indiana (Kelley for business), Purdue, Ohio State, Penn State, Wisconsin, UMD College Park, Pitt — recognizable schools that don't require a leap into unfamiliar territory
- 🚀 Reach tier: SMU (now reach-ish for many majors), Rice, UT Austin selective majors, top OOS flagships, T20 privates
The mistake we saw most this year was families whose list had seven reaches, three matches that were really reaches, and no real safeties. That math doesn't work in a cycle this competitive.
If you want the broader context for why local competition reshapes strategy, our piece on Frisco ISD's hypercompetitive environment covers it in depth.
What to Do With All of This
The rising senior reading this in May has roughly five months before the first applications are due. The rising junior has seventeen. That gap is the most important variable in the entire process, and it's the one most families fail to use.
Five things to do between now and Labor Day:
- 📝 Take the digital SAT or ACT once — a real, scored sitting — and decide your testing plan from the result, not from a guess
- ✍️ Draft the Common App personal statement before July 4. Real draft. Not an outline.
- 🎯 Decide your ED and ED II schools before September. Both.
- 🔍 Look up the major-specific admit rate for every school on your list. Adjust the list.
- 🏛️ Visit at least two schools this summer in a way that creates a story you can actually write about
The Class of 2026 already finished the test. The Class of 2027 is sitting down to take it. The patterns above are the answer key.
Want help building your list for the cycle ahead? Schedule a free consultation and we'll walk through your specific situation. Lone Star Scholars is based at 12800 Westridge Blvd., Ste 126 in Frisco, and works with families across Frisco ISD, Prosper ISD, Plano ISD, McKinney ISD, and the broader Collin County area.
Ready to Get Started?
Schedule a free consultation to discuss your student's goals and create a personalized plan.
Book Free Consultation
